Lead gen guide

Buying leads: a step-by-step guide

Buying leads well follows six steps: work out what you can pay per lead, define the leads you want, choose the type of source, evaluate vendors against written criteria, run a small measured test, then scale only what produces customers at a cost you can afford. Each step has questions you can answer before you spend.

Key points

  • Set your maximum cost per lead from customer value and close rateClose rateThe share of leads worked that become closed deals, such as sold jobs or signed cases. Glossary before you talk to vendors.
  • Write your lead criteria down: verticalVerticalThe industry or product category a lead belongs to, such as roofing or car accident. Glossary, geography, exclusivity, delivery, caps, consent and returns.
  • There is no single best company to buy leads from; evaluate each vendor on the same questions.
  • Test with a fixed budget, one geography and success measures agreed in advance.
  • Scale in steps, and keep reporting by source so you can see when quality changes.

How to buy leads in six steps

  1. Set your numbers

    Work out what a customer is worth, your close rate and the most you can pay per lead.

  2. Define your criteria

    Write down the vertical, sub-types, geography, lead type, delivery method, caps and consent you need.

  3. Choose the type of source

    Decide between lead generators, brokers and networks, marketplaces and aged list sellers.

  4. Evaluate vendors

    Ask each vendor the same questions and get the answers in writing.

  5. Run a test

    Buy a fixed number of leads in one area, worked by your normal process.

  6. Measure and scale

    Compare cost per customer with your target, then increase volume in steps or stop.

If you have not yet decided whether to buy at all, start with is buying leads worth it. The steps below assume you have.

Step 1: set your numbers before buying leads

Vendors quote a price per lead. You need a number to compare it with. Work it out from your own data:

  1. Take the gross profit of an average customer or case.
  2. Decide the most you will spend to win one customer.
  3. Find your close rate on inquiries, and expect it to be lower on bought leads at first.
  4. Multiply the most you will spend per customer by that close rate. That is your maximum cost per lead.

The lead cost calculator does this math. Cost per lead explains the formula and how lead pricing works explains why prices differ.

Step 2: define the leads you want

Write a short specification that every vendor receives. It stops vendors from selling you leads you cannot use, and it becomes the basis for returns.

What to put in your lead specification
ItemWhat to decide
Vertical and sub-typeFor example, car accident or truck accident; roofing replacement or roof repair
GeographyStates, counties or ZIP codes you can serve
Qualifying questionsThe form answers a lead must have, such as accident date or homeowner status
ExclusivityExclusive to you, or shared with a stated maximum number of buyers
TimingReal-time or aged; see types of leads
DeliveryPing/post, direct post into your CRM, or a file; and the hours you accept leads
Volume and capsDaily caps and a total budget for the period
ConsentA consent record with each lead that you can retrieve
ReturnsWhich reasons qualify and how long you have to request a return

For the data fields and records to require, see lead quality standards.

Step 3: where can I get leads from?

You can get leads from five main types of source. Each sells differently:

Types of lead source
Source typeHow it worksWhat to check
Lead generatorsA business that runs its own ads, sites and forms and sells the leads directlyVolume limits and whether it can cover your geography
Brokers and networksBuy leads from many generators and route each one to buyers, often by ping/postHow sources are reviewed and how exclusivity is enforced
MarketplacesPlatforms where buyers bid on or pick leads from many sellersWho the sellers are and how many buyers see each lead
Aged lead sellersSell older leads in files at a lower priceLead age, times sold and consent records; see what are aged leads
Your own marketingYou run the ads and forms yourselfTime, skills and ad budget; see buy leads vs generate in-house

For a side-by-side view of source types for MVA and home improvement buyers, see compare lead sources. What is a lead broker and lead marketplace explain those models.

Step 4: what is the best company to buy leads from?

There is no single best company to buy leads from. The right vendor is the one whose leads match your criteria, arrive the way your team can work them, come with consent records, and produce customers at a cost below your target. Find it by asking every vendor the same questions:

  • Which verticals, sub-types and geographies do you cover, and at what volume?
  • Where do the leads come from, and how are traffic sources reviewed?
  • Is each lead exclusive? If shared, with how many buyers?
  • How old is a lead when it reaches me, and how is it delivered?
  • Can I set filters, daily caps and the hours I accept leads?
  • Does each lead come with a consent record, and can I retrieve it on request?
  • What validation runs before a lead is sold to me?
  • Which leads can I returnReturnA buyer's request for credit on a lead that fails agreed standards, such as a disconnected number, a duplicate or a lead outside the filters. Glossary, within what period, and how are credits applied?
  • What contract length and payment terms apply?
  • Can I start with a small test?

Warning signs: no clear answer on where leads come from, no consent records, no return terms in writing, "exclusive" without a written definition, or pressure to commit a large budget before a test. A longer vetting framework is in how to evaluate a lead supplier.

Before the test: get your intake ready

Most failed lead tests fail on the buyer's side of the handoff, not the vendor's. A lead that arrives when nobody can call it, or lands in a CRM field nobody reads, looks like a bad lead in the report. Check these before the first lead is sent:

Intake checks before buying leads
CheckWhy it mattersHow to confirm it
Delivery hours match calling hoursA lead delivered when the phones are off goes cold before anyone sees itSet the vendor's delivery schedule to the hours your team works leads
Field mappingForm answers the vendor sends must land where your callers lookSend a test lead end to end and open it as a caller would
Who calls, and how oftenBought leads need the same owner and attempt pattern every timeName the person or team and write the attempt sequence down
Opening lineThe person filled in a form about a specific need, not a general inquiryWrite a first sentence that refers to what they asked about
Consent record storageYou may need to show the consent record laterConfirm where each record or certificate link is stored
Return requestsReturns only work if someone files them inside the windowAgree who checks leads against the specification and files returns

For the questions that tell real-time and aged leadAged leadA lead sold some time after it was captured rather than at the moment of submission. Glossary types apart on your intake team, see types of leads.

Step 5: run a test

  1. Pick one geography and one sub-type you serve well.
  2. Set a fixed test budget, large enough for your normal close rate to produce several customers.
  3. Agree the measures and the review date before the first lead arrives.
  4. Set up delivery into your CRM and test it with the vendor before going live.
  5. Work every test lead with your normal process: same callers, same attempts, same scripts.
  6. Tag every lead with its source so results stay separate.

A test run by a different process from the one you will use at volume tells you little. If you buy from two vendors at once, run them side by side on the same terms.

Step 6: measure the results and scale

What to measure after a test
MeasureHow to calculate itWhat it tells you
Contact rateLeads reached divided by leads receivedData quality and follow-up speed
Appointment or intake rateAppointments or signed intakes divided by leads receivedLead intent and your script
Close rateCustomers divided by leads receivedThe number that sets cost per customer
Return rateLeads returned divided by leads receivedHow often leads miss your criteria
Cost per customerNet spend after credits divided by customersWhether buying leads pays at this vendor

If cost per customer is below your target, increase volume in steps and keep watching each measure. If it is above, check follow-up speed and criteria first, then decide whether to adjust or stop. See lead conversion rate for what moves close rates.

Buying MVA or home improvement leads? Tell us your states and criteria and we can discuss a test.

When to pause, narrow or drop a lead vendor

A vendor that worked in the test can change later: a traffic source is added, a filterFilterA rule that decides which leads a buyer is offered, based on fields such as vertical, sub-type, state, ZIP code, homeownership or accident details. Glossary is loosened, or a sub-type starts arriving that you did not order. Keep the source tags from the test and watch for these signs:

Signs a lead source has changed, and what to do
What you seeWhat it often meansFirst action
Contact rate falls while your process is unchangedPhone or email data has got worse, or leads arrive later than beforeAsk the vendor which sources changed, and check delivery time stamps
More leads fail your specificationA filter was dropped or the form changedFile returns, and send the vendor your written criteria again
People say they never asked to be contactedThe consent path or the traffic behind it may have changedPause delivery and ask for the consent records for those leads
Close rate falls on one sub-type onlyThat sub-type now comes from a different sourceNarrow your filters to the sub-types that still close
Cost per customer rises above your targetAny of the above, or your own follow-up has slippedCheck your intake first, then lower caps or stop

Pausing is usually a matter of setting a cap to zero, so agree how caps are changed before you need to. How lead returns work covers the return side.

Contract terms to get in writing

  • Lead definition: the criteria from your specification.
  • Exclusivity: exclusive or shared, with the number of buyers.
  • Returns: qualifying reasons, the window to request, and how credits work.
  • Consent records: what comes with each lead and how to request the full record.
  • Caps and pausing: how to change volume or stop delivery.
  • Contract length and payment terms: how long you are committed and when you pay.

Summit Leads is a lead generation brokerage that buys and sells leads by ping/post in MVA / personal injury and home improvement, and checks for an active supplier in a buyer's states before a test. Leads are exclusive by default, rates are discussed on a call, and return terms are agreed on the onboarding call. See for buyers.

Common mistakes when buying leads

  • Talking to vendors before setting a maximum cost per lead. You have nothing to compare quotes against.
  • Vague criteria. Without a written specification, you cannot return leads that miss it.
  • Testing too small. A handful of leads cannot show a close rate.
  • Scaling before the result is clear. Large volume hides problems that a test would show.
  • Not checking consent records. Ask for a sample before you start, not after a complaint.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best company to buy leads from?

There is no single best company. Evaluate vendors on lead source, exclusivity, delivery, filters, consent records, validation, return terms and contract terms, then run a small test and compare cost per customer.

Where can I get leads from?

From lead generators, brokers and networks, lead marketplaces, aged lead sellers, or your own marketing. Each sells differently, so check source, exclusivity, consent and returns.

How do I buy leads for my business?

Set your maximum cost per lead, write down your lead criteria, choose a type of source, evaluate vendors on the same questions, run a small test, then measure and scale.

Is it better to buy exclusive or shared leads?

Exclusive leads cost more and remove competing callers from the same seller. Shared leads cost less and need very fast follow-up. See exclusive vs shared leads.

How many leads should I buy for a test?

Enough for your normal close rate to produce several customers, so the result is not down to luck. Work it back from your close rate and set the budget before the first lead arrives. A test that is too small cannot show whether a source works.

Related guides

Buying MVA or home improvement leads?

Tell us your verticals, states or ZIP codes, daily caps and delivery method. Return terms are agreed on the onboarding call.

Or write to team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email.

What happens next

  1. Step 1: You email us.
  2. Step 2: We reply by email.
  3. Step 3: Return terms are agreed on the onboarding call, before you go live.

Generating traffic? Join as a publisher.

Related in insurance: How to buy insurance leads.

Buying or selling leads? Talk to us.

Email team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email. You can also message Summit Leads or Russell Brown on LinkedIn. Contact details.