Lead gen guide

Lead gen agency or bought leads: what agencies do, when a broker fits

What does a lead gen agency do?

It plans, builds and runs campaigns that bring inquiries to your business, under your brand and on your own forms. You pay the agency for its service and pay for the ads separately, and the leads belong to you.

Should you hire a lead gen agency or buy leads?

Hire an agency if you want leads under your own brand, own the ad accounts and data, and can carry the media cost while campaigns are tuned. Buy leads from a broker or pay-per-lead seller if you want a known price per lead that matches your filters and need volume in states where you do not advertise.

Key points

  • A lead generation agency sells its time and skill; the client pays for the ads and owns the results.
  • A broker or pay-per-lead seller sells finished leads; the client pays only for leads that match its filters.
  • An in-house team gives the most control but takes the longest to build.
  • Before signing with an agency, settle who owns the ad accounts, landing pages, consent language and lead data.

What does a lead gen agency do?

A lead gen agency plans, builds and runs the campaigns that bring in inquiries for your business. The leads come in under your brand, on landing pages built for you, and they belong to you. The agency’s job is to make each lead cost less and convert better over time.

A typical engagement follows these steps:

  1. Discovery

    The agency learns what you sell, where, to whom, and what a good lead looks like for your team.

  2. Setup

    It sets up or audits ad accounts, tracking, landing pages and forms, and writes the consent language with your input.

  3. Launch

    It launches campaigns in the channels you agree: search, social, display, video or others.

  4. Delivery

    Leads reach your CRM, inbox or call team directly from your forms.

  5. Optimization

    The agency adjusts targeting, ads, pages and budgets based on which leads turn into customers.

  6. Reporting

    It reports spend, leads, cost per lead and, if you share sales data, cost per customer.

Some agencies also handle email follow-up, appointment setting or CRM setup. Ask what is included, because the term covers a wide range of services. For the wider topic, see the lead generation guide.

How a lead generation agency is paid

A lead generation agency is paid for its service, not for each lead. The common fee structures are:

  • Monthly retainer. A fixed fee for ongoing management.
  • Setup or project fee. A one-time fee for building accounts, tracking and landing pages.
  • Fee tied to media spend. A fee that rises and falls with the budget the agency manages.
  • Performance bonus. An extra fee when agreed targets are met, added to one of the fees above.

The media (the money spent on ads) is separate. It is either billed by the ad platforms directly to your card or account, or paid by the agency and passed on to you. Either way, you pay for every click or impression, whether it produces a good lead or not. That is the main difference from buying leads.

Agency contracts often set a minimum term and a notice period. Read both before signing, and agree on a review point after the first months, when you compare the agency’s results with what you expected.

Lead gen agency vs lead broker vs in-house

Businesses that want leads have three main routes: hire an agency, buy leads from a lead broker or pay-per-lead seller, or build an in-house team. The table compares them on the points that decide which one fits.

Lead gen agency vs lead broker or pay-per-lead seller vs in-house team
Lead gen agencyLead broker or pay-per-lead sellerIn-house team
Who runs the campaignsThe agency, for youThe broker’s sellers, or the seller itselfYour staff
Who pays for the mediaYouThe broker’s sellers, or the sellerYou
What you pay forThe agency’s service, plus mediaEach lead that matches your filtersSalaries, tools and media
Who carries the cost riskYouMostly the broker or sellerYou
Who owns the leads and dataYou, if the contract says soYou own the leads you buy; the source stays with the sellerYou
Brand on the formYoursUsually the seller’s site, not yoursYours
ExclusivityEvery lead is yours aloneExclusive or shared, as agreedEvery lead is yours alone
Time to first leadsAfter setup and launchOnce delivery is connected and testedAfter hiring and building
Control over targeting and adsShared with the agencyThrough filters and caps onlyFull
What you keep if you stopAccounts, pages and data, if you own themThe leads already boughtEverything

A lead broker differs from a single pay-per-lead seller in one way that matters to buyers: it works with many sellers, so it can fill more states, filters and volume, and it handles returns and billing across all of them. See what is a lead broker.

When each option fits

An agency fits when

  • You want leads under your own brand, from your own pages.
  • You have a media budget and can carry the risk while campaigns are tuned.
  • You want to own the ad accounts, the data and what the campaigns learn.
  • You lack the staff to run campaigns but want more control than buying leads gives.

A broker or pay-per-lead seller fits when

  • You want a known price per lead instead of paying for clicks.
  • You need volume soon, or in states where you have no marketing presence.
  • Your intakeIntakeThe process a law firm or its intake team uses to screen a potential client, collect the facts of the accident and injury, and decide whether to take the case. Glossary team can call leads quickly and work them to a close.
  • You want to test a new state or service before you spend on campaigns.

An in-house team fits when

  • Lead generation is central to your business and you will run it for years.
  • You can hire people with media buying, tracking and landing page skills.
  • You can fund a learning period before campaigns are efficient.

Many businesses combine routes, for example running an agency or in-house team for their brand while buying leads to fill gaps. Buy leads vs generate in house goes through that decision step by step.

What changes for your intake team when leads are bought, not from an agency

Agency leads and bought leads land in the same CRM, but they are not the same to call. Plan for these differences before the first bought lead arrives:

Agency leads compared with bought leads, from the intake team's side
Lead from your agency campaignsLead bought from a broker or seller
Whose form the person filled inYours, under your brandThe seller's site; the person may not know your name yet
Opening line on the first callCan refer to your ad or offerShould refer to the request the person made
Consent recordCaptured on your form, stored by youCaptured on the seller's form; get it with the lead
A lead that is not workablePaid for through the media either wayCan be returned under the agreed return terms
What you tune when results slipAds, pages and budget, with the agencyFilters, caps and sources, with the seller

If you will run both, decide in advance how duplicates are handled: a person who fills in your form and a seller's form is one prospect, and the bought copy may be returnable as a duplicateDuplicateA lead for a consumer the buyer has already received within a set lookback period, from the same source or another one. Glossary. Exclusive vs shared leads covers what each delivery term should mean in writing.

Questions to ask a lead generation agency before you sign

  • Will the ad accounts be in our name, and do we keep them if we stop?
  • Who owns the landing pages, forms and the lead data?
  • Who writes the consent language on the forms, and does it name our business?
  • Where is each consent record stored, and can we get it for any lead?
  • Which channels will you use, and which will you not use?
  • How is media billed: directly to us, or through you with a markup?
  • What do you report, how often, and will you report cost per customer if we share sales data?
  • What is the minimum term, and what is the notice period to cancel?
  • Who reviews ad claims for our industry’s advertising rules?

Consent matters more than most clients expect. If your team will call or text leads with an autodialerATDS / autodialerAn automatic telephone dialing system, a category of equipment regulated by the TCPA. Glossary or prerecorded message, the form must capture the right consent. See TCPA consent.

Is Summit Leads a lead gen agency?

No. Summit Leads is a lead generation brokerage. It buys and sells web form leads by real-time ping/postPing/postA real-time selling method in which a lead is pinged to buyers with partial data, buyers bid, and the winning bidder receives the full lead by post. Glossary, and it does not run campaigns for clients. Our team has 7 years of combined experience in lead generation.

Where an agency charges for its time and bills the media on top, Summit has no setup fee and no monthly fee: buyers pay only for leads delivered that match their filters. Rates are discussed on a call, and terms and returns are agreed during onboarding.

Summit Leads works in MVA, roofing, bathroom, windows, gutters, siding, flooring, HVAC, solar and insurance (auto, home, life and final expense). Leads are exclusive by default, shared on request, and filtered by state or ZIP code and by project or case type. Every lead carries a TCPATCPAThe Telephone Consumer Protection Act, the federal law that governs telemarketing calls and texts, autodialers, prerecorded voice messages and the Do Not Call Registry. Glossary consent record. Summit works with web form leads, not calls or live transfers, for now. Before a test, Summit checks it has an active supplier in your states, and new partners start with a small test. See become a lead buying partner or, for multi-trade buyers, home improvement leads.

On the supply side, publishers run traffic to Summit offers, and every publisher is reviewed before going live. See the publisher program.

Want leads without running campaigns, or want to run traffic to MVA and home improvement offers? Email us.

Common mistakes when hiring a lead gen agency

  • Letting the agency own the ad accounts. If you leave, you lose the history and have to rebuild.
  • Judging by cost per lead alone. Cheap leads that never answer the phone cost more per customer.
  • Not sharing sales outcomes. An agency that cannot see which leads closed can only tune for volume.
  • Signing a long term before a test period. Agree on a review point before committing for longer.
  • Treating an agency and a broker as the same. One sells a service, the other sells leads. Compare them on cost per customer.

Frequently asked questions

Is a lead gen agency the same as a marketing agency?

A lead gen agency is a marketing agency that measures its work by leads, such as form submissions and booked calls. A general marketing agency may also work on brand, design or public relations, where results are not counted in leads.

Who owns the leads a lead generation agency produces?

Usually the client, because the leads come in through the client’s campaigns and forms. Confirm it in the contract, along with ownership of the ad accounts, landing pages and consent records.

Can I use a lead gen agency and buy leads at the same time?

Yes. Many businesses run their own campaigns through an agency and buy leads to fill states, services or volume the campaigns do not reach. Track each source separately so you can compare cost per customer.

How do I measure a lead gen agency’s results?

Track each lead to an outcome: contacted, qualified, sold. Divide total cost (agency fees plus media) by the number of customers to get cost per customer, and compare that with your other lead sources.

Does Summit Leads charge a setup or monthly fee like an agency?

No. Summit has no setup fee and no monthly fee. Buyers pay only for leads delivered that match their filters, rates are discussed on a call, and new partners start with a small test.

What is the difference between a lead gen agency and a lead broker?

An agency runs campaigns for you and you pay for its service and the media. A lead broker buys leads from many sellers and resells them, and you pay a price per lead that matches your filters.

Related guides

Buying leads or running traffic?

Buyers: tell us your verticals, states or ZIP codes, daily caps and delivery method. Publishers: tell us your traffic sources, states and expected volume in MVA or home improvement.

Or write to team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email.

What happens next

  1. Step 1: You email us.
  2. Step 2: We reply by email.
  3. Step 3: Return terms are agreed on the onboarding call, before you go live.

Buying or selling leads? Talk to us.

Email team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email. You can also message Summit Leads or Russell Brown on LinkedIn. Contact details.