Life insurance

Exclusive vs shared life insurance leads

What is the difference between exclusive and shared life insurance leads?

Exclusive vs shared life insurance leads differ in how many agents receive each lead. An exclusive lead goes to one buyer and sells once at a higher price per sale; a shared lead goes to several buyers who each pay less. Life sales often take more than one conversation, so many life agents prefer exclusive leads, and every buyer expects you to disclose the model.

How does Summit route life insurance leads?

Summit buys life insurance web form leads by real-time ping/post, each with a TCPA consent record. Exclusive or shared routing is agreed with each buyer during onboarding, and payment and return terms are agreed with each supplier during onboarding.

Summit Leads buys and sells life insurance, final expense, IUL and mortgage protection leads by real-time ping/post.

Written for life lead sellers, this guide looks at why life agents ask for exclusivity more often than auto agents, how the choice plays out in your revenue and consent wording, and what to put in writing for buyers. It covers industry practice. Summit's routing for insurance leads is agreed during onboarding. Summit currently works with web leads (form fills), not calls or live transfers.

Key points

  • An exclusive life lead has one owner. A shared life lead is split between a capped group of agents.
  • Life sales are slower and often need an appointment, so exclusivity is worth more to many life agents.
  • A form that feeds a shared program needs consent wording broad enough for every agent in the group.
  • Put the model in writing for each buyer, and keep exclusive leads out of every later sale.

Exclusive vs shared life insurance leads compared

Exclusive and shared life insurance leads, from the seller's side
ExclusiveShared
Buyers per leadOneSeveral, up to the number stated in your terms
Price per saleHigherLower for each buyer
Times the lead is paid forOnceOnce per buyer that takes it
Consent languageMust cover the buyer that callsMust cover every buyer that may call
Life buyers that commonly use itAgents who set appointments or run longer sales conversationsCall centers with fast dialing and short scripts
Resale laterNot allowed after an exclusive saleAllowed only if your terms with each buyer say so

Why many life agents ask for exclusive leads

A car insurance shopper often compares quotes in one sitting and buys from whoever is fastest. A life insurance shopper usually takes longer. The agent may need to discuss the reason for coverage, ask health questions, run quotes with several carriers and set a second call or an appointment. If several agents call the same person in the same hour, the person often stops answering, and the slower sale suffers more than a quick auto quote would.

That is why exclusive life insurance leads are a common request, especially for permanent life, IULIUL (indexed universal life)A type of permanent life insurance in which the interest credited to the policy's cash value is linked to a stock market index. Glossary and mortgage protection. Final expense buyers with fast call teams work shared leads too. For the buyer's view, see exclusive insurance leads.

How the choice changes what you earn

With exclusive, you know what a lead earned the moment it sells. With shared, the result only shows up later, once you see how many agents in the group actually bought each request. Life buyers set tight age and coverage filters, so a shared group can be smaller in practice than it looks on paper.

Example: a seller moves its final expense traffic to a shared program, expecting several agents per lead. Most requests match only one agent's age filter, so most leads are bought once, at the lower shared price. That traffic would have earned more as exclusive.

Returns add up differently too. In a shared program every agent in the group has its own returnReturnA buyer's request for credit on a lead that fails agreed standards, such as a disconnected number, a duplicate or a lead outside the filters. Glossary terms, so a wrong number can come back from each of them. Validation pays off faster as the group grows. For the factors behind each price, see what life insurance leads are worth.

Every agent who dials a life lead has to be able to point to the person's agreement to hear from them. In a shared program, that means the wording beside your submit button has to reach every agent in the group, by name or by a clear description buyers accept. An agreement to hear from one agency gives a second agency nothing.

Life buyers often have their own rules on how the consent must identify them; ask before you launch. Background is in one-to-one consent, prior express written consent and insurance lead consent and documentation. Nothing here is legal advice; ask a lawyer to review shared-program consent wording.

Disclosure to buyers

Every buyer should know, in writing, how each lead is sold:

  • Whether the lead is exclusive or shared, and for shared leads the most buyers any one lead goes to.
  • Whether any lead may be sold again later as an aged leadAged leadA lead sold some time after it was captured rather than at the moment of submission. Glossary, and after how long.
  • The coverage type label on each lead, so the buyer knows which product it is for.
  • How repeat submissions from the same person are handled across your sources.

Keep to what you disclosed. A buyer that pays for exclusive life leads and hears from its prospects that other agents already called will stop buying.

Running both models from one form

Some sellers run exclusive and shared programs from the same traffic, for example exclusive for permanent life requests and shared for some final expense requests. This works only when the consent language on the form covers every buyer that may receive the lead, and each lead is tagged with the model it was sold under at the moment of sale. Keep each model in its own report so you can compare sold rateSold rateThe share of a publisher's leads that sell to a buyer. Glossary, average price and returns.

Common mistakes

  • Selling a lead as exclusive and later reselling it. It breaks the terms and the buyer relationship.
  • Sharing leads under single-company consent. Consent that names one buyer does not cover the others.
  • Planning shared earnings on buyers you do not have. The shared total depends on how many buyers actually take each lead.
  • Not labeling the coverage type. A shared leadShared leadA lead sold to more than one buyer, usually up to a stated, capped number. Glossary sent to buyers of the wrong product is returned by each of them.
  • Changing the model without notice. Tell buyers before you change how new leads are sold.

Frequently asked questions

Are exclusive life insurance leads worth more than shared ones?

Each exclusive sale pays more. Whether exclusive wins overall depends on how many agents in a shared group really buy each request, which age and coverage filters often limit. Run both on the same traffic before deciding.

If a person fills out two life quote forms, is my exclusive lead still exclusive?

Yes. Your promise covers your own request, sold one time. Quote forms the person completed elsewhere are outside it.

Do final expense buyers take shared leads?

Some do, especially call centers with fast dialing. Others prefer exclusive leads. Ask each buyer, and keep to the model in your terms.

Does a shared life lead need different consent language than an exclusive one?

Yes, in scope: shared wording has to reach every agent who may call, while exclusive wording only has to reach the one buyer. A lawyer should review shared wording before launch.

Related guides

Generating insurance leads?

Email us your insurance lines, traffic sources, how consent is captured, and daily volume. Summit currently works with web leads (form fills), not calls or live transfers.

Or write to team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email.

What happens next

  1. Step 1: You email us.
  2. Step 2: We reply by email.

Buying insurance leads instead? See insurance leads for agents.

Selling leads? Talk to us.

Email team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email. You can also message Summit Leads or Russell Brown on LinkedIn. Contact details.