Publishers

How to choose a pay-per-lead network: what to ask before you send traffic

How do you choose a pay-per-lead network?

Ask every network the same questions and get the answers in writing: which leads are paid, which leads buyers can return, when you are paid, how results are reported, who owns the consent language, and whether there are active buyers for your vertical in your states. Then send the same traffic to each one and judge them on what you kept after returns.

What should a publisher ask a pay-per-lead network first?

The answers that decide most of what your traffic earns: whether you are paid on submitted, accepted or sold leads; which leads buyers can send back; and whether the network has a buyer for your vertical in the states you target before you test.

This page is for affiliates and media buyers who already run traffic and are choosing where to send it. Each check below comes with the question to ask, how to confirm the answer, and what a weak answer looks like. At the end are Summit's own answers.

Payout model: which leads are paid

Find out how the network pays. Is it a fixed cost per lead (CPLCPL (cost per lead)The amount a buyer pays for each lead it receives. Glossary) or rev share? Is the payout on every accepted lead, or only on sold leads? Two offers with the same headline can pay very differently once you know which leads count.

In ping/postPing/postA real-time selling method in which a lead is pinged to buyers with partial data, buyers bid, and the winning bidder receives the full lead by post. Glossary verticals, a fixed CPL leaves the spread between the sale price and your payout with the network. Rev share passes the sale price through to you. See rev share vs CPL.

To confirm the answer, ask for the definition of a paid lead as it appears in the publisherPublisherA company or individual that generates leads, usually through websites, ads or content, and sells them to brokers or buyers. Glossary terms, not in the sales email. Words like "qualified" and "valid" mean nothing until the terms say who decides and on what fields.

Return terms: what you keep

Ask which leads buyers can returnReturnA buyer's request for credit on a lead that fails agreed standards, such as a disconnected number, a duplicate or a lead outside the filters. Glossary, in what time window, and how a returned lead is deducted from your payout. Return terms decide how much of what you earn you keep. A network with loose return terms can take back a large share of what you earned.

Also ask how you will see returns, so you can trace them back to a campaign or ad. The guide on why leads get returned explains the common causes.

Payment terms: when the money arrives

Ask how and when you are paid, and when each payment period closes. You pay for traffic up front, so the time between buying media and being paid affects how much you can spend. Get the terms in writing before you launch.

Reporting: can you see what sells

Ask how leads are reported and how reporting is delivered to you. At a minimum, you want to see leads by tracking linkTracking linkA URL issued to a publisher for a specific offer that sends the visitor to the offer's landing page and ties the visit, and any lead it produces, to the publisher's account. Glossary and to break them down by sub ID, so you can tell which campaigns, ads and states produce leads that sell.

Without reporting at that level, you cannot tell good traffic from bad, and you cannot scale what works. See tracking links and sub IDs explained and reading your publisher reports.

Ask who writes the consent language and who stores the consent record for each lead. If consent is missing or wrong, leads can be returned or rejected, and the traffic you paid for earns nothing. On hosted landers, the network should handle this. On your own landers, it is your job.

Ask for the network's traffic guidelines too, so you know what your creative must do before you build it. See hosted landers vs your own landers and TCPA compliance.

Buyer demand: is there a buyer in your states

Ask which states the network has active buyers in for your vertical, and how leads are routed to them. A lead with no buyer in its state does not sell, however good the traffic. If you plan to target many states or expand later, ask the question state by state.

Ask how routing works as well. In real-time ping/post, each lead is offered to buyers whose filters it matches and sells to the winning bid. Read ping post explained and how lead networks work.

Verticals: depth or breadth

Ask whether the network specializes in your verticals or spreads across many. A network focused on a few verticals tends to have more buyers for those offers, landers and consent language built for those offers, and guidance that fits them. A network that covers everything may be thinner in the verticals you care about.

Running MVA or home improvement traffic? Apply and ask us any of these questions.

How to confirm what a network tells you

A good answer on a call is a starting point. Before you put real budget behind it, confirm each one:

Confirming a pay-per-lead network's answers before you scale
What they told youHow to confirm it
Which leads are paidFind the paid-lead definition in the signed publisher terms
Return termsAsk to see how a returned lead appears in reporting, with its reason
Reporting by sub IDPass test sub IDs on your first clicks and check they come back in the report
Consent handled on hosted landersRead the consent language on the lander you will send traffic to, before launch
Buyers in your statesAsk the network to confirm an active buyer for each state in your test
Traffic sources allowedGet the traffic guidelines in writing, and check your creative against them

Then run a small test with its own tracking link, and judge it once the returns on those leads are in. The guide to planning a first test campaign covers the setup.

Red flags in a network's answers

  • The paid-lead definition is only verbal. If it is not in the terms, it can change after you launch.
  • No return reasons. Returns with no stated reason cannot be traced to a campaign or fixed.
  • No sub ID reporting. You will be paying for traffic you cannot measure.
  • You are asked to edit the consent language. Publishers should not change consent text; see consent language publishers must not change.
  • Every state is "covered". Ask which states have an active buyer for your vertical today.
  • Pressure to scale before a test. A network that will not wait for your test results is not judging your traffic.

Questions to ask a network

Copy this list into your first email to any network:

  • Do you pay a fixed CPL or rev share?
  • Do you pay on every accepted lead or only on sold leads?
  • Are unsold leads paid?
  • Which leads can buyers return, in what time window, and how are returns deducted?
  • What are your payment terms?
  • How are leads reported, and how is reporting delivered?
  • Can I break results down by sub ID?
  • Who writes the consent language, and who stores the consent records?
  • Can I see your traffic guidelines before I build creative?
  • Which traffic sources are approved?
  • Do you have an active buyer for my vertical in each state I plan to target?
  • How are leads routed to buyers?
  • Which verticals do you focus on?
  • Is every publisher reviewed before going live?

Already running your own lead forms?

A pay-per-lead network is built for traffic sent to its landers. If you already collect leads on your own forms, with your own consent language, you are a lead seller, and the questions change: field specs, the consent record you pass with each lead, and ping/post integration. Start at sell your leads, or go straight to selling home improvement leads or selling MVA leads.

Summit's answers

Summit Leads answers to the checks on this page
CheckSummit Leads
Payout modelRates are discussed on a call, not by email, and payout terms are agreed during onboarding.
Return termsReturns are deducted under return terms agreed during onboarding.
Payment termsAgreed during onboarding.
ReportingLeads are reported by tracking link. Ask during onboarding how reporting is delivered.
Consent and complianceEvery lead carries a TCPA consent record. See the traffic guidelines.
Buyer demandReal-time ping/post routing. Before a test, Summit checks that it has an active buyer in each state you plan to target.
Lead typeWeb form leads only. Calls and live transfers are not taken for now.
First stepNew publishers start with a small test.
VerticalsThe publisher program has offers in MVA, roofing, bathroom, windows, gutters, siding, flooring, HVAC, solar, and auto and home insurance.

Approved traffic sources are paid social, paid search, native ad networks, and SEO and rank-and-rent sites. Every publisher is reviewed before going live. See how payouts work for the payout process. Our team has 7 years of combined experience in lead generation.

Frequently asked questions

What is a pay-per-lead network?

A company that pays affiliates for leads produced by their traffic, then sells or routes those leads to buyers. Payout models are usually a fixed CPL or rev share.

What is the most important check?

The payout model and the return terms together. They decide which leads you are paid for and how much of that you keep.

Should I choose the network with the highest CPL?

Not on that alone. A high CPL that only pays on some leads, with loose return terms, can earn less than a lower headline offer. Run every check on this page.

What is a red flag when choosing a pay-per-lead network?

A paid-lead definition that is only verbal, returns with no reasons, no sub ID reporting, or a request to edit the consent language. Any of these makes it hard to know what your traffic is worth.

What if I already run my own lead forms?

Then you are selling leads rather than sending traffic, and a lead buyer will ask about your fields, your consent record and your ping/post integration. See sell your leads.

How does Summit answer these checks?

Rates are discussed on a call, and returns and payment terms are agreed during onboarding. Leads are reported by tracking link, every lead carries a TCPA consent record, and leads are routed by real-time ping/post. Summit checks for an active buyer in your states before a small first test. The publisher program has offers in MVA, roofing, bathroom, windows, gutters, siding, flooring, HVAC, solar, and auto and home insurance.

Related

Ask us the seven questions

Every publisher is reviewed before going live. Email us your verticals, traffic sources, states and expected volume.

Or write to team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email.

What happens next

  1. Step 1: You email us.
  2. Step 2: We reply by email.
  3. Step 3: Every publisher is reviewed, and return and payment terms are agreed during onboarding, before you go live.

Already generating leads on your own forms? Sell your leads instead.

Running traffic? Talk to us.

Email team@summitleads.ai. We reply by email. You can also message Summit Leads or Russell Brown on LinkedIn. Contact details.